Close-up of British currency notes and coins, representing the financial comparison between overdrafts and credit cards in the UK

Overdrafts vs Credit Cards: Key Differences

In the world of personal finance, overdrafts and credit cards are two commonly used tools for managing short-term cash flow needs. Both offer a way to borrow money, but they serve different purposes and come with distinct features, interest rates, and terms. Understanding these differences is crucial for making informed financial decisions, especially given the trends and current market conditions in the UK.

This article will explore the current outstanding balances on overdrafts and credit cards in the UK, compare the features of each product, and discuss which is easier to obtain. Additionally, we will examine the trends driving the use of these financial products and the interest rates associated with them.

Current Outstanding Balances: Overdrafts and Credit Cards in the UK

As of the latest data, UK consumers hold significant amounts of debt through both overdrafts and credit cards. According to the Bank of England, as of 2023, the total outstanding balance on UK credit cards was approximately £57.2 billion. This figure highlights the widespread use of credit cards as a preferred method of borrowing for consumers across the country.

On the other hand, overdraft balances are typically lower but still substantial. The total outstanding balance on personal overdrafts in the UK was reported to be around £5.5 billion in 2023. Although lower than credit card debt, overdrafts remain a critical financial tool for many individuals, particularly those who require short-term access to additional funds.

Overdrafts vs. Credit Cards: How They Are Used

Overdrafts

An overdraft is a facility linked to a current account that allows you to withdraw more money than you actually have in the account. It is essentially a form of short-term borrowing designed to cover unexpected expenses or temporary shortfalls. Overdrafts can be authorized (agreed upon with the bank in advance) or unauthorized (exceeding the agreed limit without prior approval).

  • Usage: Overdrafts are often used for short-term needs, such as covering bills or expenses before a pay-check arrives. They are particularly useful for emergencies and are generally intended for short periods.
  • Limits: Overdraft limits vary depending on the bank and the customer’s creditworthiness. Typical authorized overdraft limits range from £500 to £3,000. However, unauthorized overdrafts can lead to significant fees and higher interest rates, making them a costly form of borrowing if not managed properly.

Credit Cards

Credit cards, on the other hand, provide a revolving line of credit that can be used to make purchases, withdraw cash, or transfer balances from other accounts. Each month, cardholders receive a statement detailing their outstanding balance and the minimum payment required.

  • Usage: Credit cards are versatile and can be used for a variety of purposes, from everyday purchases to larger expenses. They are particularly popular for online shopping, travel bookings, and situations where spreading the cost over several months is beneficial.
  • Limits: Credit limits on credit cards are typically higher than overdraft limits, often ranging from £1,000 to £10,000 or more, depending on the cardholder’s credit history and income.

Trends in the Use of Overdrafts and Credit Cards

The use of overdrafts and credit cards in the UK has evolved significantly over the past decade, influenced by economic conditions, regulatory changes, and shifts in consumer behavior.

Credit Cards: A Rise in Online Shopping and Flexible Payments

The trend towards cashless transactions and the growth of e-commerce have driven an increase in credit card usage. Consumers increasingly prefer credit cards for online shopping due to their convenience, security features, and the ability to earn rewards or cashback on purchases.

  • Flexible Payments: Credit cards offer the flexibility to pay off the balance in full each month or make minimum payments and carry the balance forward. This flexibility, combined with the rewards and benefits offered by many credit card issuers, has made credit cards an attractive option for managing expenses.
  • Pandemic Impact: The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the shift towards online shopping, further boosting credit card use. As a result, credit card balances have remained relatively high, even as consumers gradually return to in-person shopping.

Overdrafts: Tightening Regulations and Reduced Use

Overdraft usage has seen a decline in recent years, largely due to changes in regulation and consumer preferences.

  • Regulatory Changes: In April 2020, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) introduced new rules requiring banks to charge a single annual interest rate on overdrafts, effectively banning daily or monthly fees. This change made overdraft costs more transparent but also led to higher interest rates, with many banks now charging around 39.9% APR for authorized overdrafts.
  • Shift in Consumer Behavior: As a result of these changes, consumers have become more cautious about using overdrafts, with many opting for alternatives like personal loans or credit cards, which often offer lower interest rates and more structured repayment terms.

Interest Rates: Overdrafts vs. Credit Cards

Interest rates are a critical factor to consider when comparing overdrafts and credit cards. The cost of borrowing can vary significantly between the two products, influencing which option is more suitable for different financial situations.

Overdraft Interest Rates

As mentioned earlier, following the FCA’s 2020 regulation changes, most banks now charge a single APR for overdrafts, typically around 39.9%. This rate is substantially higher than most credit cards, making overdrafts an expensive option for borrowing, particularly if the balance is not repaid quickly.

  • Unauthorized Overdrafts: If you exceed your agreed overdraft limit, the charges can be even more punitive, with higher interest rates and additional fees, making it a less favourable option.

Credit Card Interest Rates

Credit card interest rates, commonly referred to as Annual Percentage Rates (APRs), vary widely depending on the type of card and the borrower’s creditworthiness. The average APR for credit cards in the UK ranges from 18% to 25%, but rates can be lower for those with excellent credit or higher for those with poor credit.

  • 0% Introductory Offers: Many credit cards offer 0% interest on purchases or balance transfers for an introductory period (typically 6 to 24 months), making them a cost-effective option for managing short-term debt if the balance is paid off before the promotional period ends.
  • Variable Interest Rates: Unlike overdrafts, which typically have a fixed interest rate, credit card rates can be variable, meaning they can change based on broader economic factors or the card issuer’s policies.

Which Is Easier to Get: Overdraft or Credit Card?

The ease of obtaining an overdraft or a credit card depends on various factors, including your credit history, income, and relationship with your bank.

Overdrafts

  • Easier for Existing Customers: If you have an established relationship with a bank, securing an overdraft is often easier. The bank already has access to your account history, making the approval process simpler. However, the limits tend to be lower than those of credit cards.

Credit Cards

  • Broader Access: Credit cards are widely available from numerous issuers, including banks, credit unions, and retailers. The application process is usually straightforward, and credit limits can be higher. However, approval depends heavily on your credit score, with better terms offered to those with higher credit ratings.

Making the Right Choice

When deciding between an overdraft and a credit card, it’s essential to consider your financial needs, borrowing habits, and the cost of each option. Overdrafts offer quick access to funds and can be convenient for short-term needs, but they come with high-interest rates, especially if not repaid promptly. Credit cards, on the other hand, provide flexibility and potential rewards, but they require disciplined repayment to avoid accumulating high-interest debt.

As the UK’s financial landscape continues to evolve, consumers are likely to lean more towards credit cards, particularly those offering competitive rates and rewards programs. However, overdrafts remain a valuable tool for managing short-term cash flow issues, especially for those with existing banking relationships.

Please share and like us:
Scroll to Top